Episode #61
Pros and Cons of Hiring In-house vs Agency vs Consultant
September 30, 2016

In Episode #61 Neil and Eric talk about the differences between hiring in-house, hiring consultants and hiring agencies. Listen as they highlight the pros and cons, share what works for their own businesses, and the stunning advantages of outsourcing.

Time Stamped Show Notes: 

  • 00:29 – Today’s Topic: The Pros and Cons of Hiring In-house Versus Agency Versus Consultant
  • 00:42 – Neil never hires agencies—only specific consultants
  • 01:08 – Eric has an agency but would not hire an agency
  • 02:08 – How the Forced Hiring tactic works
    • 02:10 – Using LinkedIn
    • 02:52 – The easy way is to just look for an agency
    • 02:58 – Agencies do not fully understand your product
  • 03:18 – Be mindful of relationship dynamics
  • 03:26 – Think about why you want to hire
    • 03:34 – In-house for managing the whole process
    • 03:42 – Freelancer for a specific task
    • 03:48 – Consultant for helping in strategy
  • 04:10 – It depends on the task you want to get done
  • 05:00 – Optimize costs and results
  • 05:40 – Working with the big ones means paying for the brand name
  • 06:35 – Consider your company’s culture—don’t hire solely for the results
  • 07:16 – End of today’s episode!

3 Key Points:

  1. Agencies bring convenience, but significant expense as well.
  2. Hiring for what you need done and what fits your culture.
  3. Don’t look at just the costs; look at the results as well.

Resources Mentioned:

  • Angel List and Indeed – Where Eric would search for consultants
  • Forced Hiring – A tactic which Eric wrote a blog about
  • LinkedIn – A social media platform where you can generate leads

Leave some feedback:

  • What should we talk about next? Please let us know in the comments below.
  • Did you enjoy this episode? If so, please leave a short review.

Connect with us:

Discover Latest Episodes

Episode
What We Would Gamble On
December 24, 2025

Neil and Eric break down smart bets from a work and investment perspective, why crypto still has upside potential, and why hiring great people only works at the right stage of business. They share rea...

Episode
AI Law Firm Hits $100M But…
December 24, 2025

In this episode, Neil and Eric break down the rise of AI hype versus real usage, using Harvey AI, Microsoft Copilot, and ZoomInfo as case studies. They discuss $8B AI valuations, low user adoption, re...

Episode
Your Hiring Strategy Is Broken (Here’s Why)
December 18, 2025

Neil and Eric break down the real hiring mix between sourced candidates and job ads, why executive hiring should come from your network, and how overwhelmed recruiting teams change the playbook. They ...